For restaurant owners · before you sign or renew

Are you sure you want Toast?

News · Oct 29, 2026

The FTC and eight states sued Toast  (opens in new tab)

See for yourself (opens in new tab)

The Federal Trade Commission, joined by the attorneys general of Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Nebraska, Oklahoma and Utah and by the people of California, filed suit against Toast in federal court in the Northern District of California.

In plain words, the complaint alleges that Toast:

  1. Pitched a “$0/month” Pay-as-you-Go plan that hides the real cost in higher processing fees and fine print. For example, the $0 covers only one terminal, though it was marketed for one or two.
  2. Charged a 99¢ online-ordering fee (Sept 2021 to July 2023) that wasn’t disclosed in restaurant contracts and wasn’t refunded.
  3. Enrolled restaurants in add-ons they didn’t sign up for, sometimes after they had asked to cancel.
  4. Made canceling a multi-step process across several departments.
  5. Advertised “24/7 support” that restaurants say they couldn’t reach.

Toast denies the allegations and says it will fight the case in court. These are allegations, not findings.

Nation’s Restaurant News ↗ · FTC press release ↗ · Nebraska AG release ↗ · Illinois Attorney General release ↗

What it means for you: whatever the court decides, know your real cost today. Add your monthly subscription, processing and add-ons, then divide by your sales. I’ll do it with you for free.

Exhibit A · Toast’s current Instagram ad

Read the fine print on the $10K switch offer

The ad says: “We’re so sure you’ll love Toast, we’ll give you $10K to switch.”

Toast Instagram ad: We're so sure you'll love Toast, we'll give you $10K to switch, with fine print below
Toast ad on Instagram, Oct 2026.

The fine print, exactly as shown:

“Offer only avail to eligible new customers agreeing to 24 month term + $750+/mth subscription fee per location. Offer ends 10.31.26. First or only eligible location must go live by 12.31.26. Terms apply.”

Do the math

$750 × 24 months = $18,000+

That’s the minimum subscription commitment per location to receive $10K, before any processing fees.

The $10K may still make sense for some restaurants. Before you sign, compare the full 24-month cost, subscription plus processing, against what you pay today.

Read what restaurant owners have said in public, in their own words, and what Toast’s own merchant agreement says in writing. Then decide with clear eyes.

  • 34 quotes from owners & operators
  • 7 recurring themes
  • Every quote linked to its source
From Toast’s U.S. Merchant Agreement, last updated Sept 10, 2025

What the contract says

Four terms worth reading before you sign. Quoted or summarized from Toast’s published agreement; your own order form may differ.

§6.2

Rates can change with 30 days’ notice

Card processing rates and other non-software fees can change “at any time during the Term” with 30 days’ written notice.

§8.1

Automatic 1-year renewals

After the initial term, it renews for successive one-year periods unless you give written notice at least 30 days before the term ends.

§8.4

Early termination fee

Remaining software subscription fees for the rest of the term, or $150 per remaining month on Pay-as-you-go, plus any software-financing fee.

§4.7 · §17 · §4.10

Toast’s software, apps and card processing run only on Toast-approved devices

What §4.7 says: the Services “may only be used on approved Toast Hardware,” and “Toast may alter which devices are approved as compatible with the Services in Toast’s discretion from time to time,” with reasonable notice in most cases.

What “Services” means (§17, Definitions): Toast’s websites, Software, the Toast Platform, Toast Apps, supported integrations with third parties, customer support, and the Payment Processing services described under Section 7 (Payment Processing) of this Agreement or any other current or future services offered by Toast. “Software” is defined as Toast’s point-of-sale restaurant, hospitality and retail management system.

In plain words: the Toast POS software, the Toast apps and Toast’s card processing must be used on devices Toast approves, and Toast decides which devices those are. Under §4.10, each Toast device also needs an active software subscription, or Toast may deactivate the device or bill the software fee for it. The agreement doesn’t say whether Toast hardware can be used with another processor or another POS.

Read the full Merchant Agreement on Toast’s site ↗

Before you sign or renew

10 questions to ask before you sign with Toast

Ask for every answer in writing, for every location. Toast’s own terms show why each one matters.

  1. What’s the exact date my term starts, and the last day I can give notice so it doesn’t auto-renew?

    What Toast’s terms sayTerms “shall automatically renew for successive one (1) year periods.” Notice is due at least 30 days before the term ends.

  2. Which of my promo prices disappear at renewal?

    What Toast’s terms sayAt renewal, “any special terms or promotions previously offered by Toast to Merchant shall no longer be valid.”

  3. Can you change my card processing rate before my term ends?

    What Toast’s terms sayToast can change “Card processing rates and other non-Software Fees at any time during the Term” on 30 days’ written notice. Keep using the service and you’re “deemed to have accepted” the change.

  4. What’s my early termination fee, in dollars, for every location?

    What Toast’s terms sayIt’s the remaining software subscription fees for the term, or $150 for each month left on pay-as-you-go. Fees apply “for the total number of Locations” on your order.

  5. Which pass-through and per-item fees will I pay, and where’s the full list?

    What Toast’s terms sayThey’re on your order form, not in the public agreement. Toast also charges “a fee for mediating and/or investigating Chargeback disputes, in addition to any other Chargeback fee(s).”

  6. When can you hold my deposits or set a reserve, and how do I get it released?

    What Toast’s terms sayToast “may require a Reserve for any reason,” and reserve funds “will not bear interest.”

  7. What can you pull from my bank account without notice?

    What Toast’s terms sayToast can debit “any bank account linked to any of Merchant’s Toast Accounts, without prior notice to Merchant,” to collect what you owe, and that authorization survives termination.

  8. If I bundle Payroll or other modules, what happens if I miss a deadline or drop one?

    What Toast’s terms sayBundle discounts come with their own special terms on your order form, separate from the public agreement. Get every deadline, and what happens if you miss one, in writing.

  9. Can I use my own processor, or reuse this hardware with another system?

    What Toast’s terms sayToast’s FAQ answers the processor question: “No. You must use Toast’s processing services.” And “You cannot install or run third-party apps on Toast devices.”

  10. If I leave, how do I get all my sales and guest data out, and how long do I have?

    What Toast’s terms sayToast can “irretrievably delete and destroy Merchant Data after thirty (30) days following the termination.”

Quotes from Toast’s public Merchant Agreement (updated Sept 10, 2025), Payment Processing Terms and support pages, accessed Oct 2026. Terms can vary by contract, so check your own order form.

Free Toast Contract Checkup

Send us your order form and latest statement.

We’ll show you your real rate per location, your renewal date, and what it costs to leave. If your deal makes sense, we’ll tell you that too.

One-page checklist

Take the 10 questions to your next Toast meeting.

A printable one-pager with every question and what Toast’s terms say. Tell us where to reach you, and it’s yours.

We’ll only use this to get you the checklist and follow up about your contract. We never sell your information. Privacy policy

The quotes below are individual experiences, shared publicly by owners and operators on Reddit, X, review sites, and in news coverage. Each one links to where it was said.

8 quotes

Support & onboarding

The most common complaint we found, and it comes up even from owners who otherwise like the system.

“Great when it works, but if you need help you may as well light it on fire.”
Chris M., Food & Beverages, 11–50 employeesSoftware Advice review · Mar 2025Source
“As a company, there's little to no support and you will need to learn how to get around the issues yourself, full stop.”
A long-time Toast operator on Redditu/pmow · r/ToastPOS · Mar 2025Source
“Customer support is lacking. Phone support is painful, Follow up by assigned managers is one sided.”
Julia S., Director of Training, Food & BeveragesSoftware Advice review · Oct 2024Source
“Their set up process is horrible. No support for the set up. Basically just have to find and then hire a guy to set it all up for you.”
Christopher M., food truck and restaurant ownerSoftware Advice review · Dec 2024Source
“…we did have to commit for two years, though, which wasn't an issue - at the time, when support existed.”
A restaurant owner on Redditu/milspobro · r/restaurantowners · Apr 2025Source
“Their hardware is great, but it's not worth the issues with customer service. Trying to complete a change of ownership for over a month.”
A restaurant owner selling their location, on Redditu/AdvertisingWest6286 · r/restaurateur · Jan 2025Source
“…we’ve had to figure out a lot of the things are on our own through trial and error as customer service hasn’t always been the best.”
A current Toast customer on Redditu/Caliboston · r/ToastPOS · Aug 2026Source
“Once you’re signed up your account manager will ghost you and the support is useless.”
A former Toast customer on Redditu/Plus_Boysenberry_72 · r/ToastPOS · Mar 2025Source
4 quotes

Processing fees & rate changes

Owners describing what they actually pay once every fee lands, and notices of increases mid-contract. (See §6.2 above.)

“…it comes out to like 3.8% in the end when my official rate is 2.35%+10 cents for one of my restaurants that uses toast.”
A restaurant owner on Reddit (says they own 4 restaurants)u/Original-Tune1471 · r/restaurantowners · Dec 2025Source
“When we signed on, it was fair and reasonable in cost. They just sent a notice that they were TRIPLING our fees. I can’t fathom how the same service for equipment that we paid for already is suddenly worth 3x’s the cost.”
A restaurant owner on Redditu/nomadPerson · r/restaurantowners · Jan 2026Source
“TOAST fees including credit card processing fees are very high.”
Julia S., ~10-year Toast user, Food & BeveragesSoftware Advice review · Oct 2024Source
“They charge so much in merchant service fees…”
A restaurant owner with 5–6 terminals, on Redditu/Upandaway2021 · r/restaurantowners · Jan 2026Source
6 quotes

Add-ons & monthly charges

Low cost to get in, then a monthly charge for each module or connection. Several of these come from owners who like the product.

“Pricing. It's not expensive to get into, but they like to add charges ( monthly ) to everything.”
Sean D., 5 stores on Toast for 7+ years (otherwise positive review)Software Advice review · Sep 2025Source
“During this time, they have added more modules and all of them cost money. Today, I was looking for tip pooling. It used to be included but now it is part of a module that costs $149 per month and includes Toast Payroll.”
A 5–6 year Toast user on Redditu/Lazy_Pineapple7669 · r/ToastPOS · Apr 2025Source
“They also nickel and dime you for everything you want to connect.”
Chris M., Food & Beverages, 11–50 employeesSoftware Advice review · Mar 2025Source
“We currently use Toast for our POS and it’s been really good however, it is VERY expensive. With 2 handhelds and a few integrations, we’re paying almost $800/ month.”
A restaurant owner on Redditu/Dontmakemebnicetoyou · r/restaurantowners · Feb 2025Source
“We’re paying $179 just to be able to connect to quickbooks.”
A restaurant owner on Redditu/Dontmakemebnicetoyou · r/restaurantowners · Feb 2025Source
“…the monthly fees, hidden fees, fees for every single thing add up and it becomes a very expensive monthly bill.”
Jessica R., 2–10 employeesSoftware Advice review · Jun 2025Source
5 quotes

Contract terms & switching

Multi-year terms, auto-renewal, an early termination fee, and a requirement to use Toast-approved hardware. (See §8.1, §8.4 and §4.7 above.)

“Locked into a 2 year contract that auto-renews in 1 year intervals if you don’t give them adequate cancellation notice…”
A former Toast customer on Redditu/Plus_Boysenberry_72 · r/ToastPOS · Mar 2025Source
“I cant cancel without a big fee and their services are not worth the money”
A Toast customer on Redditu/Yk_2506 · r/ToastPOS · Sep 2026Source
“I would have Went a different route but it’s extremely hard to switch to a different POS”
Lindsey D., verified reviewer, Food & Beverages, 51–200 employeesSoftware Advice review · Feb 2025Source
“Want to shop around for processing rates? Can't do it.”
A restaurant operator on Redditu/CanadianTrollToll · r/restaurantowners · Dec 2025Source
“I’m ripping all my toast pos terminals out. I have 5-6 terminals and one handheld.”
A restaurant owner on Redditu/Upandaway2021 · r/restaurantowners · Jan 2026Source
5 quotes

Outages & reliability

Problems during service and in the numbers, as owners describe them.

When it goes down, who picks up?

Over the past 12 months, Toast’s public status page logged 48 incidents, 19 of them major or critical. Clover’s logged 16, with 6 major or critical. Every system has bad days, and I’ll show you the record either way. What matters is whether a real person answers when yours does.

Toast status history ↗ · Clover status history ↗ · As of Oct 2026

“Bugs. Lots of weird bugs and down time during dinner service!”
Lindsey D., verified reviewer, mom-and-pop restaurantSoftware Advice review · Feb 2025Source
“NYC wine bar/restaurant in Hell’s Kitchen (@purpletongueny) is experiencing ongoing POS/payment failures with @ToastTab, significantly disrupting service and revenue.”
Marni Halasa, posting about Purple Tongue wine bar, Hell’s Kitchen, NYCPost on X · Apr 2026Source
“Today the sales and A/R reports and cash did not tie out. I called and they said it was a known problem that they are getting other calls on and they are working on it.”
LINDA F., verified reviewer, Hospitality, accountingSoftware Advice review · Aug 2026Source
“This isn’t our first major issue, and every time it takes a while to get it fixed. If you have a restaurant that does decent volume, I would suggest getting a more dependable POS with a customer service that can actually help and not just provide lip service.”
Edward M., restaurant operatorGetApp reviewSource
“Either way it is costing me too much money and I need to move.”
A multi-location restaurant owner on Redditu/delphian6 · r/restaurantowners · Apr 2026Source
6 quotes

The 2023 online-ordering fee

Context: The Oct 2026 FTC complaint alleges Toast charged a $0.99 fee on certain online orders over $10 from September 2021 through July 2023, without adequate disclosure to restaurants or guests. In July 2023, after pushback from restaurant owners, Toast reversed the fee on July 19, 2023. Its CEO wrote, “We made the wrong decision.” Letter filed with the SEC ↗ · Illinois AG release on the complaint ↗ · See the lawsuit news above

The quotes below were made during Toast’s 2023 fee rollout and reversal. The fee is no longer charged.

“These are my customers. Why are you charging my customers?”
Elias Khoury, Massachusetts restaurateurFox Business · Jul 11, 2023Source
“Today it's 99 cents. Tomorrow it could be $2 or $3. It's at their discretion. We have no control over it.”
Elias Khoury, Massachusetts restaurateurFox Business · Jul 11, 2023Source
“And now it appears to the customer like we're penalizing them for ordering online.”
Eric Stockmann, owner, Giuseppe’s Lunch and Catering, Fenton, MOFox Business · Jul 13, 2023Source
“People are incredibly angry and feel incredibly betrayed”
Elizabeth Van Wie, Zookz Sandwiches, Phoenix, AZFox Business · Jul 13, 2023Source
“I feel like [Toast] showed us that we can’t trust them to be a business partner”
Matt Wilhelmson, owner, Koehn Bakery, Butler, MOFox Business · Jul 19, 2023Source
“For my restaurant that is upwards of $400 a month. Not to mention they will still be charging a monthly fee for the service itself.”
A restaurant owner on Reddit, when the fee was announcedu/BlackAndBlue1908 · r/restaurantowners · Jun 2023Source

In fairness to Toast

Plenty of restaurants run well on Toast. A few things worth knowing:

  • BBB A+. Toast, Inc. is listed as BBB-accredited with an A+ rating.
  • Solid overall review scores. On Software Advice and GetApp, Toast averages 4.1 out of 5 across 554 reviews. Its lowest category scores are customer support (3.7) and value for money (3.8).
  • It reversed the 2023 guest fee within days of rolling it out, and its CEO publicly said it was the wrong decision.
  • You can exit on a rate increase. Under §6.2, if you don’t accept a processing-rate change and give written notice before it takes effect, you can terminate without the early termination fee (other than any software-financing fee).
  • Many of the owners quoted here like parts of the product. Their complaints are specific, which is why they’re worth reading.

Free, no obligation

Know what you’re paying before you commit.

Send us a recent processing statement, or your Toast quote, and we’ll walk through it with you line by line in a 15-minute call: the rate, the monthly charges, the contract terms, and what to ask before you sign or renew. If what you have makes sense, we’ll tell you that too.

Keith ChristyNCS PaysA card processing and point-of-sale company

About these quotes. Quotes on this page are public statements made by third parties, reproduced verbatim (an ellipsis “…” marks a trim) and linked to their original sources. They reflect the speakers’ own experiences and opinions, not verified facts or the views of NCS Pays. 2023 fee quotes date from Toast’s July 2023 fee rollout, which Toast reversed. Contract terms are from Toast’s published U.S. Merchant Agreement (last updated Sept 10, 2025); individual agreements may differ.

Toast is a trademark of Toast, Inc. NCS Pays is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Toast, Inc.

© 2026 Keith Christy · NCS Pays · 267-673-4013